NOVEL · Knowledge Centre

Blog

Fixed Gas Detection Systems and Portable Gas Detectors

Fixed gas detector systems and portable gas detectors are a requirement for protecting personnel, safeguarding plant assets, and complying with OSHA/EPA standards. The application and intended use of these two distinct product types differ from one another. To determine which system is more suitable to deploy, consideration should be given to factors such as: whether a specific area is to be kept under surveillance, which gas types are to be monitored, whether the hazard is predominantly transient or persistent, what the risk to personnel is in the designated area, and which system provides a better cost-to-benefit ratio.

Fixed Gas Detector Systems	Portable Gas Detectors
These are systems that field personnel will not operate, or even notice during their daily duties until an emergency occurs. Routine inspection is carried out when the maintenance interval arrives or when a fault warning is generated. They require no other intervention.	These are devices worn on personnel that move with them. Because operating personnel manage these units, every user must be trained on the instrument.
Ideal for areas where personnel movement is unrestricted and multiple workers operate in the same area. They are not ideal for use in confined spaces such as sewers, storage tanks, and pits.	Ideal for use in confined spaces and areas that must be entered only after safety precautions have been taken. When selected as the gas detection system for areas such as production facilities with high equipment and personnel counts, they become highly cost-prohibitive.
Power is supplied continuously and gas monitoring is ongoing. Because there is no powering on and off, there are no limitations such as warm-up wait times, etc.	To perform gas monitoring, portable instruments must be powered on each time; they require sufficient battery charge and the necessary warm-up time.
A bump test is recommended every 30-day interval.	A bump test is recommended before each use.
A wide variety of sensor type combinations is available.	Sensor type combinations are limited.
Ideal for monitoring all types of toxic, flammable, and refrigerant gases. Installed at critical points where hazardous gases are likely to accumulate.	The gas monitoring device is located wherever the workers are. Consequently, it leads to significant deviations in detecting gases that are high density and accumulate near the floor, or low density and accumulate at the ceiling.
Fixed detector sensors can have a longer operational life, because certain sensor types are physically larger than portable ones.	Because portable devices feature lightweight, handheld, compact characteristics, they generally contain smaller sensors and may have shorter service lives.
Instruments are fixed to a location that reduces the rate of wear and tear. Depending on the situation, extra precautions are taken by deploying damage-prevention accessories such as splash guards and metal cages.	The probability of experiencing wear, tear, and damage due to physical conditions and operator negligence is high.
Generally equipped with analogue and digital outputs. This allows external safety actions to be triggered (siren, beacon, fan activation/deactivation, production shutdown, etc.).	Generally, when a hazardous gas exceeds the acceptable threshold, internal alarms sound, lights illuminate, and vibration activates on the unit itself.

Combined Deployment
Once a gas leak is detected by the fixed gas detection system, a portable gas detector equipped with a probe is used to pinpoint the exact leak location in the field.
Whilst fixed systems can continuously monitor multiple hazardous gases uninterrupted within the same space, deploying a portable gas monitor is more appropriate for infrequently visited areas where measurement of a single gas or a few gases is required.